A Word to Authors

Author(s): John (Basil) Wentworth
Publication: SyncWare News
Pub Details: SyncWare News v5 n5 (Volume 5, Issue 5)
Date: May/June 1988
Pages: 3

Some budding authors may be a little uncertain about the general criteria for publishing articles in SWN. I can’t blame them, because we have never, as far as I know, compiled a hard and fast set of rules. In fact, I would argue strenuously against a rigid codification of our criteria, preferring to judge each manuscript on its own merits.

Nevetheless, something goes through my head when I look at a prospective article. Here is a rambling look at those thoughts. (And if I seem to depart from my own standards from time to time. . .well, one of my favorite quotations from Emerson says something like “foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds.”)

So here are some of my standards, in no particular order:

The article must be valid, as far as I can tell (and I’ll admit that you can put things over on me from time to time–but I’ll be chagrined every time it happens). Or we may occasionally print an honestly invalid piece, in the hope that it will provoke some thought from our readers. But I’ll never try to deceive you in this respect. If I think it’s not valid, I’ll tell you so.

Occasionaly (not often) I’ll print a trivial (or apparently trivial) article because I think an author has potential, and should be encouraged. I’ll do this sparingly, because it may not be fair to authors who are already at a higher stage of sophistication, and because it is asking a lot of patience from our readers.

My philosophy is that almost anyone can write a program, most people can (potentially, at least) write good programs, and a surprising number can write really good programs. The trick is in KNOWING WHAT PROGRAM TO WRITE. I will give strong preference to those who write what I think are the right programs. (And please don’t ask me to define “right”.)

I would hope that our readers find all of our articles informative–but I would positively delight in publishing articles that inspire our readers to think, to adapt, to experiment. As a parallel: I love good music, but I’d far rather play in a reasonably good string quartet, or brass ensemble, or the village band, or sing in a church choir that has a good conductor, than listen to the New York Philharmonic. (I would rather compose good music than any of the above, but my talents are rather limited in that direction.) I would like to think that the same attitude prevails among our readers.

I believe that a program does not have to be profound in order to be worthy of publication. Case in point, my ETAMITLU, which appeared in Vol. 5, No. 4. On the face of it, this is a very trivial program, but I would like to point out the following redeeming social virtues, to mangle the language of the courts:

1. It does something useful (after the bugs, for which I again apologize, are eliminated), and may make it possible for authors to submit manuscripts without laying out their hard cash for word processor programs that do more than the authors may need.

2. It demonstrates that there are simple ways to meet simple needs.

3. It introduces a principle that I expect will be new to a large number of our readers–namely, the use of line renumbering to simplify the process of interpolation.

I will also give preference to articles on subjects that our readers have included in their “wish lists”–assuming, of course, that they are good articles.

And, being human, I will give a strong preference to those articles that require the least editing, correction of misspellings, etc.