Text87 Plus4 is an excellent word processor but will it “leave WordStar in the dust,” as one advertisement put it? I’ve used WordStar for several years and I thought answering this question might be interesting.
WordStar was the IBM standard for several years but has lost its standing to WordPerfect — which, in turn, is now threatened by the Window programs. WordStar is still used by millions worldwide. The version I own is 5.5, which is two releases back from the current version, 7.0. The newer versions are basically the same in concept and speed. I’m using version 3.1 of Text87 Plus4 (referred to as Text87 from this point).
The computers are comparable, neither is state of the art. My QL is a standard JSU version with a 512K Expanderam and a Delta Disk I/F. The IBM XT is a 12 MHZ “Turbo” version with an older 40 MEG hard drive and 640K of usable memory. When speeds were compared I used an identical document (nearly 41,000 words, 247K) that I obtained by copying one of my stories to itself over and over. This document is about the size limit on my QL. I can still use the Help feature and the Spell Checker (not at the same time) when this document is loaded. It should be noted when testing I used the Fountext88 version of Text87 with just the default font loaded. More fonts would have bitten into the text size.
Sometimes numbers are meaningless when presented without a point of reference. A full size “hysterical” novel is about 90,000 words. A Western or Science Fiction novel is about 60,000 words. So 40,000 words in one document is impressive. I would imagine 80,000 words would be possible with the Trump Card and who knows how many with the Gold Card. I would be interested in seeing numbers from users of these interfaces.
I moved this document over to the IBM using the same method I outlined in my last letter. This time I used 9600 baud, 40,000 words took about 10 minutes to transfer via the serial ports. I had never seen a 9600 baud transfer so I was impressed by how quickly the blocks flashed by.
Finally to the comparisons. I’ve chosen categories that are important to me. Others would probably choose differently. I present them in more or less random order.
MANUAL. WordStar wins hands down here. It has one of the most thorough, well-organized manuals I’ve seen with any program. Text87’s manual is good when compared to many other QL manuals, but out of its league here.
MAIL MERGE. Again, WordStar wins hands down. This is one area that definately disappointed me in Text87. XCHANGE’s Mail Merge features compare much more closely to WordStar’s.
SPELL CHECKER. Close here. Since I can’t use the BIGGER dictionary I’m stuck with “English” spellings, which can be annoying. WordStar has a much bigger dictionary (then the one I can use), a thesaurus and short definitions, but its not as flexible. I really like the way Text87 uses the <SHIFT> <TAB> combination to fall back to wider selection of words. In one of my stories I mispelled gremlin as “gremblin.” Text87 found the right word, WordStar could not. I intend to make an American version of Text87’s spelling dictionary–“when I get the time.”
PAGE PREVIEW. This is also close. WordStar uses a WYSIWYG representation of the typestyle and allows you to zoom in and out for a closer view. It’s impressive. But there is a definate speed disadvantage. Text87’s preview does what a preview should and is very quick. Also, Text87 uses WYSIWYG in its edit mode, WordStar (for MS-DOS) does not.
SPEED. Text87 wins hands down. Using my 40,000 word document I made some tests. Text87 plus4 displays the number of words at all times. To find the number with WordStar you have to use <CTRL> K and ?. It took WordStar 1:02 minutes to do this. (It came up with 40,877 words as opposed to Text87’s 40,784. I’ve seen differences like this before on other word processors, so it didn’t surprise me.) To go to the the bottom from the top in WordStar took 23 seconds in single column, 38 seconds after I changed the layout to three column format. From bottom to top took 33 and 48 seconds. Text87 took under 1.5 seconds from top to bottom and less than a second from bottom to top. This is basically just the time it takes to redraw the screen. Replacing “the” with “zzz” took WordStar over 45 minutes! Text87 took 1:58 minutes to do this. It replaced 3,354 occurrences. To change from one column to three throughout the document took Text87 1:08 minutes, WordStar did this in 3:33. To change typestyles and reformat the text took WordStar 3:15, Text87 did this in 1:11 minutes.
LARGE DOCUMENTS. This is close for only one reason. Text87’s document size is limited by memory. It’s doubtful that you will reach this limit. WordStar, since it feeds bits of the document in at a time, can handle any size of document (in theory). Several times, during Searches and Spell Checking, it crashed when dealing with the 40,000 word document. For most purposes this is not an important consideration, however.
PRINTER DRIVERS. Text87 wins easily here, with only one proviso, WordStar specifically supports many more printers. With the 2488 driver I can use any typestyle available with my Epson LQ printer and mix them together in any way I like. With WordStar, to use double-high, for example, I have to enter in special codes and make sure I change the line highth dot commands. Don’t get me wrong, WordStar also has good printer drivers, but they are out of their league when compared to Text87’s.
FORMATTING. Text87 wins here. After I got use to its method of handling columns I was amazed at how much can be done with the program. WordStar allows multiple columns but once you start them, they have to go to the end of the page before you return to single column. As far as I can tell there are very few limits with Text87. Very impressive.
GRAPHICS. ? WordStar has the ability to use graphics in its files, but it requires the use of a companion program — INSERT. Once there the picture can be previewed with WordStar’s Advanced Page Preview feature. Since I don’t have FOUNTED89 I can’t compare Text87’s graphic capability, but I would imagine it’s not too straight forward. If my guess is right neither WordStar or Text87 is particularly strong here.
ONLINE HELP. Neither is as good as QUILL. Text87 has interactive help available, but usually you have to back out of the specific sub-command you are using to get a general area help message. WordStar will give vague instructions, but you have to know where to look. Both are adequate, but Quill spoiled me.
EXPORTING ASCII TEXT. Text87 wins here easily. WordStar works much the same as Quill, using the printer driver to write an ASCII file. You have to be careful about page length, form feeds, etc. Text87 (and the XCHANGE version of Quill) are much more direct. Text87’s ability to put Line Feeds only at the end of the paragraphs is something I’ve never seen in any word processor. A very nice surprise. I should mention that WordStar comes with a companion program to convert files to other formats. In version 6.0 (and, I assume, 7.0) it specifically supports ASCII conversions, but not in version 5.5. Even so, this is an extra step not needed with Text87.
MULTIPLE DOCUMENTS. No contest. Text87 can open up to eight documents, WordStar only 2.
EASE OF USE. Text87 would probably have the edge here. It’s hard for me to be objective because I’ve been using WordStar for so long. Once you get past the ATTACH command (difficult for me at least) you can do a lot of things easily using Text87. In some ways WordStar’s dot commands seem more direct, however.
I’m sure I’ve missed some important points. WordStar has other features that Text87 does not support. Among these are an index feature, a footnote feature and enhancements in many of its other commands (Search, for example, gives many more options — allowing you to specify full words only, etc.)
Although I won’t chuck WordStar, most of my word processing will again be done on the QL. Text87 can do about anything I need done and do it more quickly than WordStar.
Ron Blizzard — P.O. Box 54 — Weiser, ID 83672 U.S.A.
This document was printed out with a 9-pin, Seikosha SP-1200AS printer, using Fountext88.